Falsely Accused of a Hit-and-Run in Florida? Here’s What to Do Next

The Perazzo Law Firm car accident lawyers in Miami regularly handle hit-and-run accident disputes from both sides. Consider this common scenario:

You pull out of your driveway.
Later, a neighbor claims you struck their vehicle.
You know you didn’t.

Now their insurance company is calling and suggesting you may be responsible.

Can they pursue you? – Yes, they can attempt to pursue you through an insurance claim or even a lawsuit, but they still carry the burden of proving that you actually caused the damage.
Does it matter if there’s no police report? – While a police report strengthens documentation and credibility, the absence of one does not automatically make you liable, though it can affect how the claim is evaluated.
What if you don’t currently have insurance? – Driving without insurance can trigger DMV penalties and financial exposure, but it does not relieve the other party of their obligation to prove you were responsible for the alleged accident.

In Florida, disputed accident claims happen more often than people realize. Sometimes it’s pre-existing damage. Sometimes it’s a misunderstanding. Other times, it’s simply an exaggerated accusation. Being blamed for a hit-and-run can feel overwhelming, but understanding how Florida law evaluates these claims can help you respond calmly and strategically.

Can Someone File an Insurance Claim Without a Police Report?

-Yes. A police report is helpful, but it is not legally required to open an insurance claim. Insurers may investigate based on statements, photos, and alleged vehicle damage.

That said, documentation matters. If law enforcement inspected both vehicles and determined the damage did not align, that strengthens your defense. Without a crash report or physical evidence tying the damage to your vehicle, the accuser’s leverage is weaker. Insurance companies rely heavily on proof.

If you are unsure how to respond, speaking with a Miami car accident lawyer can help protect your record and clarify your rights.

What If You Truly Didn’t Hit Them?

The burden is on them to prove liability. Insurance companies must show that damage patterns match, paint transfer aligns, and the height and angle of impact are consistent. Witness statements and vehicle inspections can be critical.

Florida follows a comparative negligence system. You are not automatically responsible simply because someone says you are. Fault must be supported by evidence.

What If You Don’t Have Insurance?

Driving without required insurance in Florida is illegal and can lead to DMV penalties. However, lack of insurance is separate from fault. Even if uninsured, they must still prove you caused the damage. While uninsured drivers face increased financial risk, being uninsured does not automatically make you liable.

Should You Speak to Their Insurance Company?

You are not required to provide a recorded statement. It is reasonable to request communication in writing and ask for evidence supporting their claim. Adjusters are trained to secure admissions and shift blame, so proceed cautiously.

Can They Sue You?

Yes, anyone can file a lawsuit. But filing is not the same as winning. They must prove contact, causation, and matching damage. Without physical evidence or a police report, their case may be weak.

If you receive a demand letter or court paperwork, consult a Miami car accident lawyer immediately. Early legal guidance can prevent a minor dispute from becoming a serious legal problem.

Speak With a Miami Car Accident Lawyer Today

If you are being accused of a hit-and-run or pressured by an insurance company, don’t navigate it alone.

Call 888-PERAZZO for a FREE initial consultation, available 24/7, or schedule Online.

The Perazzo Law Firm will review your situation, explain your options, and help you take the next best step before a small issue becomes a larger legal challenge.